Maybe check with a few of the performance companies and see what their experiences have been?
The problem is that although they can say that their products are "safe", none of these companies will pay a single cent to you if your car ends up needing repairs as a result of their products. Some of them offer warranties on the product they sell, but they all have clear disclaimers that release them from liability if their product causes damage to your car.
Many of them also advertise that their products offer "up to" a certain performance level, the key word is "up to". Technically their product could add 1hp and still be correct according to their claims. Are their some that offer real performance benefits- yep. Are they worth the risk of damaging your car? Nope. As soon as you plug it in and reprogram the ECU, you likely will void your powertrain warranty. Honda will be able to blame almost any problem on the reprogramming.
Ultimately, there's not much regulation over these companies- so they can say almost anything that they want. The reputable ones- Hondata and Ktuner- are likely reliable because they are established companies- but even they have dislaimers on their website that indicate that you're on your own once you buy their product. Hondata, for example, has a return policy of three days. Their website also says that if you make the foolish mistake of trying to sue them (which according to their website, you pretty much can't), you will be responsible for any damages and court costs- including any and all legal fees they incur as a result of your lawsuit.
Ktuner's website also clearly states that their products are for "off road research and development testing only". Ktuner doesn't seem to offer any actual warranty at all on their products. On the bottom of their website, they indicate that issues will be handled "case by case". In other words, you have no guarantee that they will support their products. Good luck trying to get them to pay for any damage their product causes to your car.
Again- both websites make lots of performance claims- but they both clearly state that their products will deliver "up to" those claims. Hondata indicates that their Stage 1 product can provide
up to a 20-25hp / 20 ft lb of torque increase. Their Stage 2 is advertised as providing
up to a 11hp / 40-50 ft lb of torque increase. Their state 3 is advertised as offering
up to a 45hp / 60 ft lb of torque increase. Their website shows a graph of which part of the RPM range will offer you the increases in power. With Ktuner, they advertise the following increases (all labeled as "up to"): Stage 1: 30hp/38 ft lb of torque. Stage 2: 55hp / 58 ft lb of torque. There are a few other options that can theoretically push your engine even further.
But at what cost to reliability? Is Honda's tiny 1.5t engine really designed to perform at those levels? Are the engine and transmission components going to continue to operate reliably at those performance numbers?
So I ask the question again to the original poster. You indicated that your budget wouldn't allow you to buy a 2.0t. Will your budget cover an expensive repair or the replacement of your engine or transmission if you push your car past its limits?
Or save your money for a project car. Have a reliable daily driver and a warrior for the weekend. Best of both worlds without the anxiety of destroying a new car.
Yes 100%.